Skip to main content

Unison over SCP for Storage Synchronization

Unison is a file synchronization tool that allows you to keep two directories (or filesets) synchronized, even if they reside on different machines or operating systems. It excels at handling conflicts gracefully and ensures data consistency. A common and secure method of using Unison is over Secure Copy Protocol (SCP), which provides encrypted data transfer via SSH. This document provides an overview of Unison, how it works with SCP, its benefits, and how to set it up.

What is Unison?​

Unison is more than a simple file copy utility; it's a bi-directional file synchronization program. This means it can detect changes in both directories and propagate those changes appropriately. It's particularly useful for:

  • Local and Remote Synchronization: Keeping files synchronized between a local machine and a remote server.
  • Backup and Replication: Creating backups of important data by synchronizing it to another location.
  • Collaborative Workflows: Sharing files and code among multiple users on different machines.
  • Cross-Platform Synchronization: Synchronizing files between machines running different operating systems (e.g., Windows, macOS, Linux).

Key Features of Unison:

  • Bi-directional Synchronization: Detects and propagates changes in both directions.
  • Conflict Detection and Resolution: Identifies conflicts when the same file has been modified in both locations and provides mechanisms for resolving them.
  • Efficient Transfer: Only transfers the necessary changes, minimizing bandwidth usage.
  • Secure Transfer: Supports secure protocols like SSH/SCP for encrypted data transfer.
  • Cross-Platform Compatibility: Works across different operating systems.
  • Preservation of Metadata: Preserves file permissions, timestamps, and other metadata.
  • Atomic Updates: Ensures that file updates are performed atomically, preventing data corruption.
  • Graphical and Command-Line Interface: Offers both a graphical user interface (GUI) and a command-line interface (CLI).

How Unison Uses SCP​

Unison can leverage SCP (Secure Copy Protocol) to establish a secure, encrypted connection between the local and remote machines. SCP relies on SSH (Secure Shell) for authentication and encryption. When using Unison over SCP:

  1. SSH Connection: Unison initiates an SSH connection to the remote machine using the specified username and hostname (or IP address).
  2. Authentication: The SSH connection requires authentication, which can be done using passwords or SSH keys. SSH keys are generally recommended for enhanced security and automation.
  3. Encrypted Data Transfer: All data transferred between the local and remote machines is encrypted using SSH's encryption algorithms.
  4. Unison Protocol: Once the secure connection is established, Unison uses its own protocol to communicate with the Unison process running on the remote machine, exchanging information about file changes and resolving conflicts.
  5. File Transfer via SCP: The actual file transfer is handled by SCP over the established SSH connection.

Benefits of Using Unison with SCP:

  • Security: SCP provides encrypted data transfer, protecting your data from eavesdropping.
  • Authentication: SSH authentication (passwords or keys) ensures that only authorized users can access the remote files.
  • Simplicity: SCP is widely available and easy to configure.
  • Reliability: SSH provides a reliable connection, even over unreliable networks.

Setting Up Unison with SCP​

Here's a general outline of how to set up Unison to use SCP for file synchronization:

  1. Install Unison: Install Unison on both the local and remote machines. Make sure to use compatible versions of Unison on both ends.
  2. Install SSH: Ensure that SSH is installed and configured on the remote machine. Most Linux distributions come with SSH pre-installed. You may need to install an SSH server on Windows.
  3. Configure SSH Authentication: Set up SSH key-based authentication for passwordless login to the remote machine (recommended for automation). This typically involves generating an SSH key pair on the local machine and copying the public key to the ~/.ssh/authorized_keys file on the remote machine.
  4. Create Unison Profile (Optional): Create a Unison profile to store the configuration options, such as the directories to synchronize and the connection details. This makes it easier to run Unison with the same settings repeatedly. The profile is typically stored in the ~/.unison directory.
  5. Run Unison: Run Unison from the command line, specifying the local and remote directories to synchronize, along with the SCP connection details.

Example Command (Without Profile):

unison local_directory ssh://user@remote_host//remote_directory

Example Command (With Profile):

unison profilename

Where profilename is the name of your Unison profile file (e.g., myprofile).

An example unison profile (~/.unison/myprofile.prf) might look like this:

Use Cases for Unison over SCP​

  • Website Deployment: Synchronizing website files from a local development environment to a remote web server.
  • Document Management: Keeping documents synchronized between a local computer and a remote file server.
  • Code Synchronization: Sharing code between developers working on different machines.
  • Personal Backup: Backing up important files to a remote server for safekeeping.
  • Configuration Management: Synchronizing configuration files between multiple servers.

Advantages of Unison over SCP​

  • Bi-directional synchronization: SCP is primarily a one-way copy tool. Unison synchronizes in both directions.
  • Conflict resolution: Unison detects and helps resolve conflicts, which SCP doesn't handle.
  • Efficiency: Unison only transfers changed data, while SCP typically transfers entire files.
  • State tracking: Unison remembers the state of the synchronized directories, making subsequent synchronizations faster and more efficient.

Disadvantages of Unison over SCP​

  • More Complex Setup: Unison requires installation and configuration on both local and remote machines.
  • Overhead: Unison has some overhead due to its synchronization protocol.
  • Not Suitable for Real-Time Synchronization: Unison is not designed for real-time synchronization; it's more suitable for periodic synchronization. SCP alternative is a good option for this.

Alternatives to Unison​

  • rsync: A powerful file transfer and synchronization tool, often used over SSH. Rsync is a one way sync from the source to destination only.
  • Syncthing: A continuous file synchronization program that uses peer-to-peer networking.
  • Nextcloud/ownCloud: Self-hosted cloud storage solutions that provide file synchronization and sharing capabilities.
  • Seafile: An open-source file syncing and sharing solution designed for high reliability and performance.

Conclusion​

Unison, when used over SCP, provides a secure and reliable way to synchronize files between different machines. Its bi-directional synchronization, conflict resolution capabilities, and efficiency make it a valuable tool for a variety of use cases. While it requires more setup than a simple SCP transfer, the benefits it provides in terms of data consistency and ease of use make it worth considering for scenarios where file synchronization is critical.